Stage 0
| A | B | C | D | E | F | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Supply chain | Finnøy Bioenergy | ||||
| 2 | Process stage | 0 – General vision | ||||
| 3 | Sustainable indicator | Vision | Enablers | Indicators | Level units | Comments/Gaps |
| 5 | Economic | Keep value-creating in the agriculture | Large-scale contra smallscale operation | Capasity | 8 mill kwh | Estimated potensial. Based on manure, but can theoretically be more with other ingredients |
| 6 | Social - cultural | “The green region” - The green community | Increase greenhouse production as “green products” based on biogasenergy | Positive image New renewable energy Co2 used back to growing plants | >80% rating (questionaire) | |
| 7 | Economic | Keep the position as the greenhouseregion no.1 in Norway | Biogas | New renewable energy production | 6 mill. kwh in step 1 | within 2013 |
| 8 | Social | Build up a strong greenhouse cluster | Education at local/regional academy - operating staff | Level of knowledge | realise one project with greenhouse cluster | Then the result is that it will end out in some concret |
| 9 | Ecologic | Stabilies climate challenges | Less pollution – less use of non-renewable recourses | Saving of Co2, and new renewable energyproduction | Change from fossile energy to bio energy for more than 2 HA | HA =Hectar Greenhousearea |
| 10 | Soc - ecol | Easy progress | Make Ros-analysis scheme | Scheme to be used by municipality | Under progress | |
| 11 | Economic | Increase agricultural profit | Reducing fertilizing production budget New energyproduction | Energy performance Improved efficiency | Get more than 3 Nok/kg 'green ' tomato | Min 10 % increase (The sum of less expenses and more income) |
| 12 | Economic | Protect/conserve agricultural areas | New energyproduction Reducing fertilizer budget | Area | Min. 42 MS in Norway | MS = marketshare or prosent |
| 14 | Storyline: | In Norway the electrisityprice are low. That are making problems to get good economy in biogasprojects. | ||||
| 15 | The department are working with green sertificates for new renewable energy, but the frameworkconditions are not ready. | |||||
| 17 | CHP can get green sertificates, but not if its get money from Enova or Innovation Norway |
Stage 1
| A | B | C | D | E | F | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Supply chain | Finnøy Bioenergy | ||||
| 2 | Process stage | 1 – Material supply | ||||
| 3 | Sustainable indicator | Targets | Enablers | Indicators | Level units | Comments - Gaps |
| 5 | Ecol | Less use of fertilizer | Use of waste from biogasproduction, we have to eksport as much as we import | Quantity of fertlizer | Reduce use of fertilizer with min 10 % | |
| 6 | Ecol | Ensolve problems with to small spreadareas | Production of biogas -Breed improvement of wasteproduct | Quantity in and out from plant | Step 1 22ooo m3 cattle manure | 18 000 cattles and 4000 pigs = 22 000 |
| 7 | Econ | Find useful use of “organic waste” | Rawmaterials to biogasproduction: Use local rawmaterials | Tons of rawmaterials needed in the biogasreactor | 2000 tons of 'salmon 3000 ton pigsmanure 1500 ton manure hens 11000 cattlemanure | salmon from Grieg seafood. 40-70 N-øre pr. kg. Today the farmers pay about 5 Nok kg to destruate dead hens leaves from tomatoproduction in step 2 |
| 8 | Econ | Find useful use of “waste” from biogasproduction | Fertilizer for sale and own use - less fosfor in future - big value | Quality: Use purpose Price Form (liquid/firm) | Develop a reciep for sale of posphor(fosfor) | Research - Take out phospfor as a clean product (fragmentation) - BATMAN-project (Bioforsk og CBMI) Have not secured manure, No agreements, Have not secured waste from fishindusty |
| 9 | Econ/ecol | Easy start up | Bring bacteriaculture from Åna fengsel(jail) | Price and quality | Better and eaisier than researching and development (fou) | |
| 10 | Sos | Secure rawmaterial (enough) | Make agreements of intensions | Amount raw material Price and volume | Need min. 50 % of the farmers. |
Stage 2
| A | B | C | D | E | F | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Supply chain | Finnøy Bioenergy | ||||
| 2 | Process stage | 2 - Logistics | ||||
| 3 | Sustainable indicator | Targets | Enablers | Indicators | Level units | Comments - Gaps |
| 5 | Econ - ecol | Minimal transport, pollution, cost, time and investments | #Coordinate out – and in transport #Ecuipment collaboration #Store collaboration | Loads./. Weights, costs Price transport with own equipment | 50 Nok/ton | 15 m3 adherent (wagon) a 750 kr/hour = 50 Nok/ton Unsure |
| 6 | Soc - cult | Ensure sos. Acceptance | Info/communication | Positive image | >80% rating (questionaire) | |
| 7 | Ecological | Eksport of nutriants | Produce manure/fertilizer for export (heilgjødsel) | Price for transport | Research | |
| 8 | Ecological | Minimal transport of rawmaterials to biogasproduction: #Fish from local fishfarms #Tomatoes from greenhouses #Manure from farms #Waste from households(food) | Bigger units – capasity. Storestank, vehicle, boat | Loads / weights Capasity Frequences Economy Transportnoice Transportsafety | Research |
Stage 3
| A | B | C | D | E | F | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Supply chain | Finnøy Bioenergy | ||||
| 2 | Process stage | 3 – Energy production | ||||
| 3 | Sustainable indicator | Targets | Enablers | Indicators | Level units | Comments - Gaps |
| 5 | Soc | Energy from biomass that is able to compete with naturegas and el. | Build up local competence. Technical workers | Level of knowledge | Educate min 5 person each year - local | Reasons for building av plant - Sentral questionaire: Shall the plant be build to solve problems with spreadareas (manuredirective and Eus waterframework), the wastequantity, the need to solve climatechallenges and meet the market by producing "green tomatoes", to solve the energyneed, or to secure and provide settlement. |
| 6 | Econ - soc | Long-range profitt to the agriculture | Local value-creating in all positions | Employment, profit | Keep the level up to days | |
| 7 | Econ | Predictable trade of energy | Levelling out periods with low use | Price electrisity Price heat | 50 øre/kwh max | |
| 8 | Ecol | Minimize environmental impact | Use CO2 and CH4 (metan) –supply to greenhouses, Use waste in agriculture | Co2 equivalent, Quantities per waste type, size of spreadarea/land | ||
| 9 | Econ | Assure high materials efficiency | Pretreatment, boiler- technology Continius optimization | Energy performance Improved efficiency | Total 12 mill nok in investmets | Lundsby have give an offer to build the plant. Is at UIS for qualitysecuring. |
| 10 | Econ | Low operational costs | Technology | Costs per production unit | 6-7 mill. kwh | 40 øre kw/h drift.3 kr/kwh investment |
| 11 | Econ | Low operational costs | Financing | Interest rate, security | 6% | Internrente |
| 12 | Econ | Low operational costs | Employees | Competencies | Best competence i Norway | KER (Competence Energy Ryfylke) Project |
| 13 | Econ | Assure high materials efficiency | Process technology | Energy performance | Simular to 3 mill. kwh | 40 øre kw/h drift.3 kr/kwh investment |
| 14 | Soc | Provide and secure employment | Cost/benefit calculation | Employment | Min 5 persons | |
| 15 | Soc - cult | Ensure sosial acceptance | PR/info campaign, collaboration with local authorities | Positive image | >80% rating (questionaire) | Nothing done so far. Have invited several times to open meetings, but almost nobody is coming |
Stage 4
| A | B | C | D | E | F | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Supply chain | Finnøy Bioenergy | ||||
| 2 | Process stage | 4 – Grid distribution | ||||
| 3 | Sustainable indicator | Targets | Enablers | Indicators | Level units | Comments - Gaps |
| 5 | Econ | Energy for stakeholders use | Short distance Localisation near tradearea | Distance | Max 1 km | Because of to high costs connected to investments. Must maybe have several smaller plants |
| 6 | Econ | Delivery of gas exsessed own use??? | Delivering to Lyse Neo– existing gasnet | Price gas - guaranties | ? | Lyse have to give costgaranties for min 20 years using their grids Alt 1. Own powerplant Alt 2. connecting to Lyse |
| 7 | Econ | Hot water to municipal buildings | Pipelines to be planned | Price heat Price grid | 50 øre /kwh + nett /grid rent | 80 N-øre tot Unsure- only actual if the greenhouseconsept doesnt work |
| 8 | Econ | Production of electrisity in periods | Sale to main electrisitylines | Price electrisity | 50 øre /kwh + nett /grid rent | 80 N-øre tot Unsure |
| 9 | Sos - econ | Organisation by competence | 1. Production of electrisity, gas 2. Technical solutions 3. Contractors 4. El. net and gridowners | Competencelevel, references, costs | Best know how about operation and biogas plant and grids in Norway | Some contractors, producers of rawmaterials and energy and others try to get contracts within areas they dont have the right/nessesary competence |
Stage 5
| A | B | C | D | E | F | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Supply chain | Finnøy Bioenergy | ||||
| 2 | Process stage | 5 - Consumption | ||||
| 3 | Sustainable indicator | Targets | Enablers | Indicators | Level units | Comments |
| 5 | Part A: Econ - sos | Greenhouses | Stakeholders own production – via existing and new pipe-net | Price electrisity Price heat | 50 Øre/kwh | |
| 6 | Econ | Municipal buildings | Plant location – show lower price level for biogasheat contra hydroelectrical | Price electrisity Price heat | 50 øre/kwh | |
| 7 | Econ | Private households | Plant location – show lower price level for biogasheat contra hydroelectrical | Price electrisity Price heat | 50 øre/kwh | |
| 8 | Econ | Industrial use | Plant location – show lower price level for biogasheat contra hydroelectrical | Price electrisity Price heat | 50 øre/kwh | |
| 9 | Part B: Ecol | Soilimprovement in the agriculture – own analysis | Manureproducts from biogasplant | Price | 50 nok/ton | 15 m3 adherent (wagon) a 750 kr/hour = 50 Nok/ton |
| 10 | Econ | Extend the season of growth | Production of tomatoes through the whole year | Walue | Increase production(longer season) with min 12 kg tomatoe/ square meter | Average today are 40-45 kg/m2 - increase/step up with 12 kg/m2 |
| 11 | Ecol | Mantain the nutrean balance | Biogas-waste from production to spreadarea and gardens | Area | Nutrean/m2 | research |
